Casino Bike describes Sheriff Colt as a medium volatility slot with an RTP of 96.13%, sticky wilds, re-spins, collectible scatters, and two bonus games with multipliers. The review highlights: "Trust no one, be on your guard. Sheriff Colt online slot created by developer Peter & Sons introduces you to this legendary personage, the law in the southern town of White Crow, where bandits surround you like wolves in search of prey." Features like sticky wilds triggering respins and super free spins with a 3x multiplier are praised. The overall tone is positive, noting the balance between simple gameplay and rewarding features.

AboutSlots calls Sheriff Colt 'a beautiful, basic, and easy-to-understand game with features to keep you interested in continuing to play.' The review lauds its unique, high-quality graphics and lively character animations, saying: "Even adding the small detail of the sheriff brandishing his Colt pistol makes the game more 'lively.'" Features like sticky wild symbols, free spins, and super free spins with multiplier all receive favorable mentions. The game is considered solid for fans of western-themed slots, though the hit frequency for the top prize is extremely low.

Slots Temple rates Sheriff Colt as a medium volatility slot with high-quality animated graphics, stating: "The cartoon-like quality and animated icons tell a story, which makes Sheriff Colt feel much more immersive than your standard online slot game." The review notes the game's unique free spins round and immersive western atmosphere. It also points out the limited number of paylines and loudness of the soundtrack. A player quote: "The more scatters you catch, the more you fill up his whisky bottle, which means free spins all around. Yee-ha!" Overall, the reception is positive with some criticism about originality in theme.